Showing posts with label Research. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Research. Show all posts

How to Write Critical Appraisal for Qualitative Study?

Author: Sana Rehman

This qualitative research is about the attitudes and approaches towards the vaginal atrophy when there is menopause in females and they have to face vaginal atrophy. The results were collected from the focus groups discussion of multicultural settings. These focus groups were composed of females who were experiencing vaginal atrophy after menopause and the results were collected based on personality types and the psychological factors. The study findings depicted that the responses and treatment concern for vaginal atrophy among females depends upon personality types (Utian & Maamari, 2014). The Following steps would highlight ''How to write critical appraisal for qualitative study''.

Steps of the Research Process

The purpose of the research was to collect the responses from females towards the vaginal atrophy after menopause. The focus groups discussion comprised on three-four hours and maximum 3-5 women have been a part of this focus groups. Hence, the research method for this study was the preference of focus groups to obtained the in-depth information. After FGD's, the results were presented considering the personality types of females. It was found out that those females who had individualism and stongth decision making power had taken the treatment for vaginal atrophy. In contrast those women who were submissive and had instincts of belongingness were not provided with any treatments. Their health care physicians satisfied them that vaginal atrophy is a part of aging and requires no treatment. However, it was concluded at the end of the research that the responses and approach for treatment to vaginal atrophy was based on the personality types. The findings of the study will help thefthe to understand how their personality types are interlinked with their perception towards health. 

Strengths and Weaknesses of the Qualitative Research

Congruency between the research questions and the research methodologies is the strength of good research (Lockwood, Munn & Porritt, 2015). This research has a good congruency because the research question is well explained with the help of the results collected during the focus group studies. The other strengths of this study are to make the females aware that vaginal atrophy is a medical condition and they need to take it seriously. They must see a doctor and if they are facing any severe or mild difficulty, they need to tell the doctor or their health care provider. Another strength of this research is the selection of focus groups at international level which shows that this problem prevails all around the world and females face and combat this issue according to the personality types. The research can make them stimulated to have awareness about this topic and to address this issue with the wise approach. This is so because they have all the rights to talk about their physical issues and must not hide or ignore such issues. The study is also important because all the females in the world have to pass through a phase of menopause and then they develop certain changes in their bodies and vaginal atrophy is one of them. Another positive goal of the study is the use of personality-based approaches to treat the females and to create awareness among them. This research highlights the issues and concerns about the health of females. The weakness of this research is realized when only a small fraction of respondents are included in the focus groups. Another weakness is felt that doctors or care providers have not been included in this research. So, the opinions of only females regarding the issue were recorded.

Credibility and Reliability of the Results

Good research also has unbiased goals and presentation of the results irrespective of the cultural perspectives. This shows that quality research is based on theories and facts and is not biased with the cultural backgrounds of the researcher (Lockwood, Munn & Porritt, 2015). Hence, this research is shown at an international level without considering the cultural perspectives. Only one thing was taken into account during the research and it was the medical reason of the females. The research is both credible and reliable, because it was based on a careful focus group discussion and the problems were observed and recorded all around the world that females are facing vaginal atrophy after the menopause. So, the international issue of females has come under observation and the research has put enough contribution to highlight the revolving factors. A lot of females in the world are facing this issue and there is a need to create awareness to deal with this issue and counseling of the females is needed to be done to promote awareness among them. Couselling services will help them get better health status and strenght to deal with their genuine medical issues.

Questions for Peer Follow-up

1-      The results of this research show that vaginal atrophy treatment is dependent on the personality types of the females and according to me there might be some other reasons behind this. What is your input in this regard?

2-       In the research methodology, only women were selected from four counties and the research is given the name of the international study. Is not it a partial study in which other countries needed to be added at a broad level? What is your stance on this insight?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Critical Appraisal



Introduction
The sedative medication has become a necessity in clinical practice to reduce the pain and anxiety among patients. In particular, the paediatrics experience substantial fear, anxiety before dental treatment and express noncompliance behaviour. The current study provides a critical appraisal of a meta-analysis to investigate the effect of midazolam medication to reduce the anxiety and pain among children.
What type of qualitative research design was utilized to conduct the study?
The meta-analysis was carried out to assess the effect of midazolam in paediatrics before dental treatment. 
Are the results valid/trustworthy and credible?
The results were found to be trustworthy as the recognised journals were approached to explore the answer such as Embase, SIGGLE, the WorldWideWeb, Medline, Community of Science Database. Thirty-eight studies were chosen from the latest researches published in the recognised journals of Embase, SIGGLE, the WorldWideWeb, Medline, Community of Science Database. The accuracy of completeness of the data was assured through the data extraction process. The articles that were found to be highly relevant and fluffing the criteria were included in the study. The irrelevant articles with unambiguous results were excluded from the study. The results were found to be valid according to the literature that has been included in the study. According to other studies, the results were found to be consistent with the literature.   Are implications of the research stated?
The implications of the research have not been stated, but it increased the insight regarding the dire needs of the sensitive situation before dental treatment. Also, it has increased the understanding of how to much medication dose should be given to the patients before dental treatment to avoid pain and anxiety.
What is the effect on the reader?
The results of the study were plausible, as the substantial data supported the fact that oral midazolam decreases the pain, agitation, and anxiety before surgery among children (Kim et al., 2016: Linares et al., 2014). A large body of research suggested that sedative medication such as midazolam is effective for pediatric to reduced the anxiousness ad pain (Fazi, Kurth, Jantzen, Watcha & Rose, 2001).
What are the results of the study?
The results of the study indicated that the literature has weak evidence regarding the effectivity of midazolam use before dental treatment among children. The research approach was not much accurate for the study due to a lack of recent data, and the least number of articles were included in the study.
How does the researcher identify the study approach?
The researcher identified the study approach through literature, and the data collection approach was not accurate. The data extraction has not been made for several reasons.
The data collection approach was accurate as the researcher approached high ranked journals, but he did not primarily focus on the recent data; rather, he included studies from 1966 to onward. The researcher should include lasts five or above years of articles to provide the updated information to enhance the implication and validity of the research.
Is the significance/importance of the study explicit?
The significance of the study was mentioned, as the current study provided substantial information regarding the effectiveness of the midazolam does not reduce pain and anxiety among patients. The findings of the current study contradict with the literature as according to the literature, midazolam reduces anxiety and pain among children undergoing surgical treatment. The potential contribution of the study was to provide contradictory and unique results.
Is the sampling clear and guided by study needs?
The sampling of participants and articles were clear and according to the need of the study but the selection of sample found to be least effective. The sample size and composition were reflecting the needs of the study. As far as the phenomenon of human experience is concerned, the constructs were identified in terms of experimental and plausible effects. The sources of data collection and verifying data were clear, and the role of the researcher and activities were explained thoroughly. Almost 28 oral and nitrous oxide has been used in the current study to investigate the effects.
Are data analysis procedures described?
The data analysis procedures were well described and provided the direction of guidance. The thirty articles were reported to be at the high risk of bias and six were found to be at the low risk of bias. The standardised mean difference was carried out to assess the average outcome with the 95%CL 1.58, P< 0.001 and I2 found to be equal 91%. The weak evidence from five trails found to be at high risk of bias, which indicates the weak relationship between midazolam and cooperative behaviour for treatment or reduction of anxiety or pain.
How are specific findings presented?
The data finding has been presented in the qualitative and descriptive form. The writing of the articles effectively promoted comprehension regarding the concerned phenomenon. The detailed description has been given for each step, but unfortunately, no conclusion can be drawn from the study which sedative provide the high results to control the behaviour, anxiety and pain.
Will the results help me care for my patients?
The results were found to be the least valid and reliable in terms of clinical practice. Still, the finding would help me in providing the best care to my patients understanding the needs and desire of the patient. The result could vary in the situation as a few patients might get an advantage after taking midazolam pill, while some other might get no effect. The results were moderately relevant to patient values and circumstances. However, the results may be applied to clinical practice in terms of individual difference. Each case and child is unique and reacts differently to the medication. The low mg of midazolam can work effectively for some patient; in contrast, the high dosage might be effectless. The study provided an understanding of how the literature provides a substantial difference in the effect of midazolam.
Conclusion
The metanalysis provided a detailed description of the effectivity of midazolam for dental treatment. The study was found to have a few gaps that would be covered in further studies to assess the implication and significance of the current study. Further studies should also be overviewed to assess the validity of the current study.